|
"We understand life backwards, but we live it forwards." With these words from Kierkegaard, Fr John Behr introduced the SVS 2009 Summer Conference. The conference, which promised to examine "20th-century landmarks towards a 21st-century Church," devoted most of its time examining the past. But as Prof. Peter Bouteneff later pointed out, the study of the past is always undertaken in order to understand the present and shape the future, so the problem then lies in how to interpret or "spin" the past.
In presentations by Fr Alexander Garklavs, and later by Fr Hyacinthe Destivelle, Scott Kenworthy, and Vera Shevzov, the Moscow Council of 1917-18 and the vision of St Tikhon were shown to have direct influence on the shape of church life and its structures of authority. Looking to a more recent past, Fr Cyril Hovorun and Matthew Namee sought to critically examine the way in which aspects of 20th century Orthodox Church history in America have been presented. Fr Cyril noted that autocephaly has carried something of an aura - a mythical dimension, as he called it - which went far beyond its obvious canonical implications. Namee dismantled the what he saw as the simplistic notion of early 20th century Church unity under Russian auspices.
Fr. Leonid Kishkovsky discussed the reality of communion between the various Orthodox Churches that led to the proclamation of autocephaly for the Orthodox Church in America, as well as the varying states of communion between Churches since 1970.
Looking further back for insight into the present, Bishop Basil of
Amphipolis explored in a fresh way the contemporary implications of
Chalcedon's Canon 28, which had placed the churches in the "barbarian
lands" under the care of the See of Constantinople. He argued that
under the canon's internal logic, North America might properly be
claimed by the ancient Patriarchate of Rome, and that the Patriarchate
of Constantinople ought to be considered a temporary administrator in
view of the Great Schism.
The conference decisively arrived at the present in its concluding
session on Saturday afternoon, when Metropolitan Jonah gave a detailed
vision for the present and future, solidly founded on the past century
that had been so closely examined during the previous two days. (The
text of his speech is available here.)
Referring frequently to the "kenotic" vocation of the OCA, calling
himself "the least among equals," he said that the OCA would joyfully
meld itself into "a fully autocephalous united Church in North America,
embracing all Orthodox, and freely electing its own hierarchy and, in
time, its own patriarch." Along the way, he offered several practical
suggestions for interim steps.
Responding to His Beatitude's paper were Charles Ajalat (Chancellor
of the Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of America), Fr Mark Arey
(General Secretary of SCOBA, and Ecumenical Officer of the Greek
Orthodox Archdiocese of North America), Archimandrite Luke Murianko
(Abbot, Holy Trinity Monastery, and Rector, Holy Trinity Seminary,
Jordanville), and Archbishop Nathaniel of Detroit and the Romanian
Episcopate (OCA).
Apart from its content, this conference was remarkable for its wide
availability to those who were not physically present. Broadcast in
streaming video on the internet through St. Andrew House, and archived
in audio on Ancient Faith Radio, the lectures and discussions were
being viewed remotely by between 100 and 190 people - with a total of
over 2,500 log-ons to the site, from all over the US and from 25
different countries. Questions received through e-mail by remote
viewers were relayed to and addressed by the speakers.
The questions and comments that came electronically expressed profound
gratitude for the opportunity to be "present" at the conference in this
way. Many also expressed a degree of frustration at the amount of time
devoted to the study of the past, when they wanted to address the
burning issues of the present and the future, of a North American
Orthodoxy that is in crisis.
Indeed, the conference did not address all the contemporary crises, nor
did it solve contemporary problems. But it did lay some vital
groundwork for how these may be addressed concretely. One of its main
contributions was the gathering of hierarchs, clergy, and lay leaders
from multiple Orthodox jurisdictions in North America in order to
reflect deeply and critically, and together, on the past and the
present. In attendance were five members of the OCA Holy Synod
(including the primate), several members of the OCA Metropolitan
Council, seminary faculty, staff, and trustees, including Bishop Savas
of Troas (Greek Archdiocese), as well as over one hundred registered
attendees and countless visitors on the webcast.
In addition, the true sacramental unity all Orthodox Christians share
in Christ was manifested by the celebration of the Divine Liturgy on
Saturday morning in the Seminary Chapel. By sharing in the one cup of
the Eucharist, the disjunction between the unity we preach and the
disunited way in which we administer our churches was both highlighted
and put in its proper perspective.
Click here to view a gallery of photographs from the Summer Conference.
|